Shame and Guilt in Recovery

Fear, hope, uncertainty–these are just a few of the emotions a person might feel when they go into recovery. Among them, shame and guilt can be two of the most challenging to face. These feelings might emerge as you reflect on the past or begin to confront the impact of addiction on your life, but they’re also an opportunity for growth and self-compassion. By learning how to deal with shame and guilt in recovery, you can build a stronger foundation for healing. 

What is Shame?

Shame is an emotion that occurs when someone believes they’ve fallen short of their own expectations or those set by others. Unlike guilt, which focuses on specific actions, shame is more internal and centers on a negative perception of oneself. 

People experiencing shame often feel unworthy or flawed, making it difficult to connect with others or seek support. When shame is unspoken or unacknowledged, it could potentially lead to behaviors like withdrawing from loved ones or avoiding situations that could trigger feelings of inadequacy.

Why People Feel Shame in Recovery 

In recovery, shame may be tied to the stigma that surrounds substance abuse. Society frequently labels substance use as a moral failing or lack of willpower, which can reinforce a person’s negative beliefs about themselves. This stigma can make recovery even more challenging. For many, shame becomes part of a harmful cycle called the ‘shame addiction cycle’ in which: 

  • People turn to substances to numb or escape feelings of shame.
  • Continued substance use results in consequences like social isolation, damaged relationships, or health issues that intensify the feeling of shame. 

Feelings of inadequacy can fuel the desire to self-medicate, making it challenging for some individuals to break free from this cycle. 

What is Guilt?

Guilt is an emotion that arises when someone feels responsible for a negative outcome and is accompanied by a sense of remorse or regret. Unlike shame, which focuses on self-worth, guilt is tied to actions and behaviors. People experiencing guilt may feel disappointed in themselves or saddened by their choices, especially when those choices negatively affect others.

Why People Feel Guilt in Recovery

As people reflect on their past actions and their effect on others during recovery, they may feel guilty. This sense of guilt could be influenced by personal values, cultural expectations, and the consequences of substance use. Common reasons for guilt in recovery include: 

  • Recognizing harm caused to family, friends, or others
  • Reflecting on past behaviors and feeling disappointed in oneself
  • Struggling with unmet family or cultural expectations
  • Facing the consequences of neglected relationships or broken trust

Can Guilt and Shame Negatively Impact Recovery?

Guilt and shame can both influence the recovery process, but they do so in different ways. While guilt can sometimes encourage people to reflect on their actions and make positive changes, shame tends to have a more damaging impact. 

The feelings of regret and remorse in guilt might motivate someone to take responsibility for their actions and make amends. For example, a person in recovery might feel guilty about neglecting relationships during their substance use but use that guilt to fix those connections. However, guilt isn’t always helpful. When it becomes chronic or excessive, guilt can spiral into constant self-criticism, thus making it harder for someone to focus on their recovery. 

On the other hand, shame can feel heavier and more personal. People who experience high levels of shame may avoid taking responsibility altogether or turn to unhealthy coping mechanisms to escape the discomfort. They are also more likely to stay stuck in dysfunctional patterns as shame can make people defensive, avoidant, or aggressive.  

How to Overcome Shame and Guilt in Recovery

While guilt and shame are common feelings during the recovery process, they can become overwhelming and difficult to manage if they’re not addressed. Fortunately, there are some things you can do to help you overcome these emotions and focus on what matters most: your recovery. 

Attend Therapy and Counseling

One way to deal with shame and guilt during recovery is by attending therapy or counseling. A trained therapist can help individuals understand where their feelings come from, how they affect their life, and how to respond to them in healthier ways. Here are common therapies that may be beneficial for those in recovery: 

  • Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) helps shift negative self-perceptions by replacing self-critical thoughts with more compassionate and realistic ones. 
  • Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) provides tools for managing intense emotions and learning healthier ways to handle guilt and shame. 
  • Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) encourages individuals to accept difficult feelings while focusing on values and meaningful actions. 
  • Mindfulness-based stress reduction helps people become more aware of their emotions and respond to them with greater self-compassion. 
  • Motivational interviewing uses open-ended questions to explore personal motivations, affirms strengths to build confidence, and reflects on a person’s perspective of their addiction. 

Group therapy and 12-step programs also reduce feelings of isolation and create a sense of belonging as they allow those in recovery to share their experiences in a safe, understanding space. Benefits include: 

  • Connecting with others in recovery helps individuals realize they’re not alone. 
  • Hearing others share their struggles and successes can make it easier to open up about personal experiences. 
  • Sharing stories within a group encourages connection and normalizes feelings of shame and guilt, which can help individuals feel understood and supported. 

Additionally, research shows that the skills learned in therapy can continue to make a difference long after the sessions end. By learning to use tools like recognizing and reframing negative thoughts, managing emotions, and handling triggers, individuals are better equipped to stay on track and overcome hurdles they may encounter on their recovery journey.     

Practice Self-Compassion and Mindfulness

Practicing self-compassion and mindfulness can help those in recovery deal with tough emotions, like guilt or shame, in healthier ways. Research shows that when people treat themselves with kindness and stay present in the moment, they’re less likely to rely on substances to cope. 

Here are some ways to practice self-compassion and mindfulness: 

  • Talk to yourself the way you’d talk to a friend. If you’re being hard on yourself, pause and choose more supportive and loving words. 
  • Write yourself a letter of encouragement. Imagine what someone who cares about you would say, and put it into words you can revisit when you need a little boost. 
  • Try mindfulness meditation. Spend a few minutes focusing on your breath and letting your thoughts come and go without judgement. Guided meditations can help if you’re new to this. 
  • Keep a gratitude list. Jot down a few things you’re thankful for each day as a way to gently shift your mindset. 
  • Use grounding techniques when your emotions are too much to handle. Try noticing five things you can see, four you can touch, three you can hear, two you can smell, and one you can taste. 
  • Practice positive affirmations. Remind yourself that you’re trying your best and deserve patience and care. 
  • Take time to do something that makes you happy or calm. Consider going for a walk, listening to music, or reading a book. 

Over time, these habits can help you feel more at peace with yourself.  

Forgive Yourself and Others

Addiction might leave people feeling guilty or ashamed, but it’s important to remember that you’re not defined by your mistakes. You’re human, and like everyone else, you’re allowed to learn, grow, and move forward. 

Self-forgiveness helps you let go of the blame you may carry. It allows you to focus on the progress you’re making instead of being weighed down by the past. Forgiving yourself can also improve your relationships. When you’re caught in self-blame, it’s easy to rely too much on others for reassurance and support. Research shows that the more people dwell on their mistakes, the less likely they are to apologize or repair the damage.

Forgiving yourself is important, but so is forgiving others. Holding onto anger or resentment can keep you stuck in a cycle of negative emotions, which increases the risk of relapse as a way to escape those feelings. Forgiveness doesn’t mean that you condone someone else’s behavior, but it does give you the emotional space to heal.

Let Mission Harbor Behavioral Health Help You Heal

Shame and guilt are challenging emotions to experience, but they don’t have to hold you back from recovery. With the right support, you can work through the weight of these feelings and turn them into an opportunity for growth. 

At Mission Behavioral Health, we understand how overwhelming recovery can be, especially when you’re feeling an array of emotions. Our compassionate team offers a variety of treatments to help you get back on track and live a life substance-free. Whether you’re seeking support for yourself or a loved one, we’re here to help. Contact us today to learn how you can overcome shame and guilt in recovery.

The facilities at Mission Harbor are staffed with trained experts to best assist patients with their mental health issues. We are capable of dealing with any and all cases with a licensed staff, equipment, and approved techniques. Our mission is to help those who want to help themselves, and we support your decision in seeking help.

Get Help Now

Addiction is extremely difficult to overcome on your own. Seek specialized help and let professionals guide you in your recovery.